How to Buy Signed Sports Memorabilia Without Getting Burned

A signed jersey, ball or photo is only worth what it costs if the signature is real, and fakes are common. These steps are how experienced collectors protect themselves. None of them cost anything.

1. Buy items a respected authenticator has already checked

Three companies are the most widely accepted by collectors and dealers: PSA/DNA, JSA (James Spence Authentication) and Beckett Authentication Services. An item they have checked carries their sticker or hologram with a number, and comes with a matching certificate or letter. An item with none of the three costs less for a reason.

2. Make sure the numbers match

The number on the sticker or hologram on the item has to match the number on the certificate exactly. If the seller cannot show you both, close up, walk away.

3. Look the number up yourself

Each company lets anyone look up a certificate for free: PSA certificate verification, Beckett Authentication Services and James Spence Authentication. Type the number into the company’s own site, not into a link the seller sends you.

4. Check that the record matches the item in your hand

A number that looks up correctly only proves that the number exists. PSA itself warns that forgers sometimes copy real certificate numbers onto fake documents. So read the record: the player, the item and any photo on file all have to match what you are buying.

5. Do not rely on a certificate from the seller alone

Anyone can print a certificate of authenticity. A certificate written by the person selling the item is not an independent check. Look for one of the three companies above, or for an item signed at a public signing that the authenticator witnessed.

6. Buy where you are protected

On eBay and other marketplaces, read the seller’s feedback, ask for photos of the sticker and the certificate before you buy, check the return policy, and pay through the marketplace so its buyer protection applies.

Unsigned jerseys and gear

For jerseys, hats and other gear without a signature, buy from sellers that carry officially licensed products. Very low prices on a current jersey usually mean a copy.

Scroll to Top